Aerophilately Judging Worksheet
Exhibit No: ______________ Frame Nos.: ____________________
Exhibit Title: __________________________________________________________________________
| 1 | Treatment and Philatelic Importance Points | |
| 1.1 | Treatment | 20 |
| • The exhibit has/has no plan/introduction page • The plan/introduction page is incomplete • The exhibit does/does not concur with title/plan • The exhibit is/is not balanced on selected periods/scope • The exhibit is/is not complete • Important parts or objects are missing • Scarce or expensive material is duplicated • The exhibit space is/is not used properly for showing relevant aerophilatelic material • Exhibited stamps/vignettes/labels must also be shown on flown covers • Many objects are not carried by air • The Subject is/is not relatively easy to complete |
||
| 1.2 | Philatelic Importance | 10 |
| • The exhibit is important/less important for aerophilately • The exhibit cover a small field of collecting • The scope should be enlarged/reduced |
||
| 2 | Philatelic and Related Knowledge, Personal Study and Research | 35 |
| • The correct items are/are not chosen for display • The displayed items are/are not properly analysed • Information about dates/postal rates/-routes/-markings are present/missing • The information given is/is not correct • Exhibits built on catalogues do not substantiate much philately • The exhibit contain many overpaid covers • The exhibit show outstanding personal research • New and original research is/is not documented • Available research is/is not used successfully • The information given is/is not balanced against the introductory plan |
||
| 3 | Condition and Rarity | |
| 3.1 | Condition | 10 |
| • The quality of the displayed material is/is not of acceptable condition • Modern material should not be immaculate • Repaired objects are not mentioned in the description • Postmarks/manuscript markings are/are not legible • Stamps/vignettes/labels shown are/are not in good condition |
||
| 3.2 | Rarity | 20 |
| • All the rare objects of the field are/are not shown • The exhibit display new-discovered items • Items of this field are/are not easy to acquire • Common material dominate the exhibit • “Philatelic made” material should be avoided |
||
| 4 | Presentation | 5 |
| • A nicely presented exhibit • Too much/little on each sheet • Lack of balance between the sheets in the exhibit • Colour photos/photocopies are to be reduced 25% • The exhibit is visually less attractive |
||
| Total | 100 |
Comments: